Being served with a restraining or protective order can be alarming, especially if you aren’t sure how the process works or what evidence is going to be used against you. Depending on the order, you could be barred from contacting family members, returning to your own home, possessing firearms, or seeing your children.
Texas law sets specific requirements for obtaining these orders, and the type of order involved will play a big role in what’s needed for someone to have an order granted.
What’s the Difference Between a Restraining Order and a Protective Order in Texas?
People often use these terms interchangeably, but they have different meanings under Texas law. The main differences include:
- Temporary restraining order (TRO): A TRO is generally issued in civil cases, often during divorce proceedings. It helps prevent certain actions while a case is pending, such as draining a bank account or selling property.
- Protective order: A protective order is issued in cases involving family violence and certain other offenses. It can limit contact, communication, physical proximity, and firearm possession. A criminal charge or conviction is not required to obtain one. However, violating a protective order can lead to arrest and new misdemeanor or felony charges.
- Magistrate’s order for emergency protection: A judge may issue this order after certain criminal arrests. It provides immediate protection without requiring a full protective order hearing.
The biggest difference is how these orders are enforced. Violating a protective order can result in criminal charges, while violating an ordinary civil TRO is typically handled through civil court, such as through contempt proceedings.
What Evidence Do Courts Consider?
Under Texas Family Code § 85.001, a judge deciding whether to grant a family violence protective order must determine if family violence occurred or not.
Because the hearing is a civil proceeding, the applicant doesn’t have to prove this beyond a reasonable doubt like a prosecutor would in a criminal trial. The standard is a preponderance of the evidence; the judge only needs to find it more likely than not that the alleged conduct happened.
Judges can consider a wide range of evidence at a protective order hearing, including:
- Witness testimony: Statements from the person requesting the order or anyone who saw the relevant events
- Text messages and emails: Communications alleged to contain threats, harassment, or admissions
- Photographs and medical records: Evidence of claimed injuries or property damage
- Police reports and 911 recordings: Documentation of past incidents or emergency calls
- Video and audio recordings: Security footage, phone recordings, and similar materials
- Previous incidents: Evidence of earlier violence or threats offered to support the allegations
A temporary ex parte protective order has different requirements. Under Texas Family Code § 83.001, a judge can issue one without hearing from the accused person first if there’s a clear and present danger of family violence.
How Can You Defend Against a Protective Order in Texas?
The right defense depends on the allegations, the available evidence, and the type of order involved.
Common approaches include:
- Presenting your own evidence: Text messages, emails, photos, and other records can provide context and help the judge understand your side of the story. Witness statements, location records, and surveillance footage may also help challenge the allegations.
- Challenging the credibility of the allegations: An attorney can look for differences between the applicant’s testimony, police reports, and earlier statements. Conflicting accounts may raise questions about the accuracy of the allegations.
- Raising legal defenses: Depending on the facts, your attorney may raise arguments involving self-defense, mistaken identity, or inaccurate claims. They can also challenge whether the alleged conduct meets the legal definition of family violence and whether the applicant has met the requirements for a protective order under Texas law.
An experienced attorney can review the evidence, identify weaknesses in the allegations, and build a defense based on the facts of your case.
Contact Chiles McGuire Criminal Law To Schedule a Free Consultation With a McKinney Criminal Defense Lawyer
A protective order hearing in Texas moves fast, and the outcome can affect where you live, your access to your children, your gun rights, and your record. Don’t try to handle it alone, and never violate the order while you contest it.
Facing criminal charges? Our experienced lawyers are ready to protect your rights and fight for your future. Serving McKinney, Collin County, and surrounding areas, Chiles McGuire Criminal Law is here to help. Schedule a free case evaluation today at (214) 432-6540.
Chiles McGuire Criminal Law
6000 Alma Rd Ste 902, McKinney, TX, 75070
Available 24/7